When it comes to choosing a main character for your story, one question you may ask yourself is whether you prefer cats or dogs. Both animals have been popular choices in literature and media, but they each bring their own unique qualities to a story.

Here are some things to consider when deciding which animal would make the better main character.

Cats: Independent and Mysterious

Cats are known for their independence and aloofness, which can make them a great choice for a character who is also a bit of a lone wolf.

They are also mysterious creatures, often disappearing for hours at a time and leaving their owners to wonder where they’ve gone. This could make for an intriguing plot point in a mystery or adventure story.

Cats are also visually interesting, with their sleek bodies and piercing eyes. They can be both beautiful and intimidating, which could add depth to a character’s persona.

Additionally, cats are often associated with magic and superstition, which could be utilized in a fantasy or supernatural story.

Dogs: Loyal and Upbeat

Dogs are known for their loyalty and upbeat personalities. They love to be around their owners and will often go to great lengths to please them. This could make for a heartwarming character in a drama or romance story.

Dogs are also versatile animals, being able to serve as both protectors and companions. This could make for an interesting dynamic in a story where the character’s loyalty is put to the test.

Additionally, dogs have a wide range of breeds, each with their own unique traits and physical characteristics.

The Pros and Cons of Each

While cats and dogs both bring their own strengths to a story, they also come with their own challenges. Here are some pros and cons of each:.

Cats

Pros:
- Independent and mysterious
- Visually interesting
- Associated with magic and superstition
Cons:
- Less social than dogs
- Can be difficult to read
- May not be as instinctively protective as dogs

Dogs

Pros:
- Loyal and upbeat
- Can serve as both protectors and companions
- Wide range of breeds with unique traits
Cons:
- Require more attention and care than cats
- May be viewed as “basic” or cliche in some genres
- Can be overly enthusiastic or needy

Genre Considerations

When deciding whether to make your main character a cat or a dog, it’s important to consider the genre of your story. Here are some examples of how cats and dogs may be better suited for different genres:.

Horror/Thriller

In a horror or thriller story, a cat’s mysterious and sometimes spooky demeanor may be more appropriate than a dog’s friendly and loyal nature.

A cat’s tendency to disappear at night or suddenly jump at unseen things could add tension to a scene. Additionally, cats have been associated with witches and other supernatural beings, which could add an element of dark magic to a story.

Romance

In a romance story, a dog’s loyal and affectionate personality may be more fitting for a love interest than a cat’s independent and sometimes aloof behavior.

A dog’s eagerness to please and be by their owner’s side could make for a heartwarming romantic gesture.

Action/Adventure

In an action or adventure story, a dog’s protective instincts and ability to sense danger may be more advantageous than a cat’s mysterious behavior.

A dog could serve as both a loyal companion and fierce protector, whereas a cat may not be instinctually as protective.

Conclusion

Ultimately, whether you choose a cat or a dog as your main character depends on the story you want to tell. Both animals have their own unique qualities and can make for great protagonists in various genres.

Consider the traits of each and how they could add to your story before making your decision.